IAVS condemns proposals that would promote cruel animal experimentation in India
The IAVS has submitted a hard-hitting statement to the Indian Government’s public consultation on proposed new rules relating to animal experimentation.
The draft regulations have already triggered strong criticism from Indian animal protection groups.
The IAVS focussed on the fundamental or structural flaws in the proposals that would leave animals almost totally defenceless. Perhaps the most alarming plan is to allow animal experimentation companies to decide themselves whether and how to carry out vivisection projects in the vast majority of cases. The nominally-independent Government regulatory committee (CCSEA) would only have oversight over experiments admitted to cause severe suffering on a few favoured species. All experiments on mice, rats and rabbits – which cover the vast majority of animal sacrificed in vivisection - will be outside the scope of independent scrutiny. The IAVS told the CCSEA:
“All applications for permission to conduct experiments on all sentient animals should be submitted to the CCSEA. Moderate severity experiments can involve significant suffering, and it is unscientific and inconsistent to exclude rodent (and other sentient) species from the protection of fair and independent scrutiny of proposals to inflict cruelty upon them.”
One noticeable feature of the proposed regulations is that parts of the corresponding EU Directive appear to have been cut and pasted into the draft, but the intended system of governance is even more incoherent and biased than the EU framework. For example, while the proposals envisage that experiments would be given a severity category, there are no measures to ensure that that will be done honestly or that excessive unauthorised cruelty is detected and punished. The new rules appear to be designed to give the public false reassurance about consideration for animals, while in reality promoting rather than preventing cruelty.
The IAVS submission concluded that the current proposed Indian regulatory system is fundamentally weaker than the system in the UK, EU and other jurisdictions due to the lack of any requirement for comprehensive independent ethical evaluation and potential controls on animal suffering:
“The proposed rules threaten to create a vague and incoherent regulatory system that will protect cruel behaviour more than innocent animals. They should be an embarrassment for any society or country that aspires to concern for animal welfare and opposition to violence and cruelty towards animals.”
Our concerns about the Indian system are exacerbated by the fact that the University of Galway has paid over 100,000 euro to an Indian laboratory to carry out animal tests on its behalf.
The IAVS will continue to monitor the CCSEA’s response to the consultation and the eventual regulatory system. We would like to thank Animal Law Ireland for bringing this to our attention and giving us the opportunity to speak up on behalf of animals threatened with abuse. You can read our submission to the Indian Government below.
Dear CCSEA
On behalf of the Irish Anti-Vivisection Society, I have the following comments on the draft rules published on 30 September 2026. Please note that we have only become aware of the call for comments in the last 24 hours, so we are confining our comments mainly to broader, structural aspects of the proposed rules. I have significant expertise in the governance of animal experiments, with a national award-winning PhD thesis on the topic, subsequent published monograph (‘The Politics of Animal Experimentation’) and over 30 years of experience in the field. I also served on the statutory National Committee to advice the Irish Government on this area of regulation for five years.
1. There are experiments which fall outside the invasive/non-invasive typology that have the potential to cause pain and suffering, e.g. those involving feeding restrictions that could lead to malnutrition. The scope of the regulations must include any procedures on an animal that could cause him/her pain or discomfort at or above the level caused by the insertion of a needle. (Rule 2)
2. All applications for permission to conduct experiments on all sentient animals should be submitted to the CCSEA. Moderate severity experiments can involve significant suffering, and it is unscientific and inconsistent to exclude rodent (and other sentient) species from the protection of fair and independent scrutiny of proposals to inflict cruelty upon them. (Rule 11)
3. All applications to conduct experiments should be subject to an independent harm-benefit assessment by the CCSEA with support from external ethics experts. The process for the harm-benefit assessment should be defined and placed in the public domain to ensure accountability. In particular, unambiguous rules regarding how levels of animal suffering should be weighed against perceived potential benefit should be published to ensure moderate/severe cruelty to animals is not permitted for clearly trivial purposes such as basic research with no direct tangible medical benefits, or moderate/severe cruelty to animals to develop/test potential medicines for non-life-threatening diseases (notwithstanding the inherent weaknesses in the translatability of non-animal experimentation data to the human context).
4. Any breaches of the predicted severity categorisation of an experiment on animals should be treated as a criminal offence on the grounds of unnecessary cruelty and breaching the initial ethical evaluation of the experiments and project that permission rested on.
5. The rules appear to concentrate on the Establishment as the focus of accountability. This would allow the actual individuals responsible, e.g. a Principal Investigator (PI), to act with impunity, causing excessive and unauthorised suffering without threat of punishment. Animal abuse by a PI could lead to infringement action against an Establishment, but the PI would be free to inflict criminal cruelty in other Establishments. (Rule 25)
6. The current proposed regulatory system is fundamentally weaker than the system in the UK, EU and other jurisdictions due to the lack of any comprehensive independent ethical evaluation and potential controls on severity and suffering. The proposed rules threaten to create a vague and incoherent regulatory system that will protect cruel behaviour more than innocent animals. They should be an embarrassment for any society or country that aspires to concern for animal welfare and opposition to violence and cruelty towards animals.
Yours faithfully
Dr Dan Lyons
Public Policy Consultant
Irish Anti-Vivisection Society
